This story is not unique: a mid-sized Midwestern town is preparing to adopt a 50-year-old neighborhood.
If you read between the lines, news of annexation often times read as case studies against low-density suburban development. This article from Mankato demonstrates (unintentionally) why these types of subdivisions can be so problematic.
All quotes related to the annexation were taken from the Free Press. I recommend reading it here first.
South View Heights No. 2 is not part of the city while everything surrounding it is. The 1960s subdivision has been leapfrogged by other development over the years, but has rejected opportunities to join city services in exchange for lower taxes.
These are homes befitting the American Dream of the 1960s. The neighborhood has nice, modest homes and is surrounded by creeks and ravines. Nothing fancy, but residents genuinely care for their homes and take good care.
For the area, these are above average homes that range in value from around $170k to $290k. The median home price is approximately $213k, which is around $40k above the local average (thanks Zillow).
After the city adopts this neighborhood, the average house will pay around $2,800 per year in taxes (up from the current $2,000). Keep these numbers in mind and ask yourself, “Will the extra $800 in extra city taxes help cover the true long-term costs?”
Water. Sewer. Roads. All in disrepair.
50 years has passed, and as the newspaper accurately puts it; “The new addition to Mankato’s family of neighborhoods is handsome enough, but it’s showing its age.”
“The water tower, obviously, is broken, and (roughly 85 percent of) the septic systems are non-compliant,” said [homeowner]. “And we have a failing water line. And the road is shot.”